Did anyone else think the editing at the end of ‘No Country…’ got a bit sloppy?

February 22nd, 2008 by Frank
No Country For Old Men

Incredible film. Dark, savage and beautiful… sloppy editing at the end doesn’t take from the experience.

Review of No Country For Old Men
Rated as 4/5 on Feb 22 2008 by Frank

4/5

Despite waiting eagerly nearly four months to see this film before finally getting to it, and despite all the hype, I was still massively impressed with No Country For Old Men. Damn this film is good.

The Coen broethers can be an acquired taste, and sometimes stray into a realm of their own where they can lose mere mortals like ourselves… but No Country injects just enough Coen magic to soar but not so much as to fly off the mark (where do I get this complete bullshit?).

Perhaps being constrained by the base material of Cormac McCarthy’s novel was what kept the film grounded in a version of American reality that is at once familiar and yet unsettlingly alien.

All the performances are excellent, Javier Bardem is a genius and his performance as Anton Chigurh is simply legendary, comparable perhaps to Eric Bana’s portrayal of Chopper for the insanity and psychosis plainly evident in the eyes.

Woody Harrelson in brief moments appears to be trying to hard, but he deserves an Oscar for his scene with Javier Bardem. Tommy Lee Jones finally gets to act again - it’s been a while since anyone gave him anything to work with, and Josh Brolin is incredibly convincing as the relatively normal man caught up in the chaos of missing drug money, hit men and crazed mexican drug dealers.

Great also to see Kelly Macdonald give a wonderfully understated and convincing performance, but Beth Grant seemed an odd choice due to the fact that she had to be made up to look older, especially when the Coen brother’s casting of smaller roles is usually incredibly authentic.

So, why four stars instead of five? The Coen brothers will be devastated that I witheld that fifth star and I’m sure it will taint forever the Oscars they will win for this film. But I had a problem with the end. While I love the plot, and have no problem with the ending from a story perspective, the editing seemed to get sloppy toward the end and the storytelling suffered as a result.

The Coen’s editing is superb throughout the film, so one wonders how they could have screwed this up, but everyone I spoke to has different opinions on certain final scenes, and I don’t mean in a good way, I just mean in a downright confused way.

Passage of time is not indicated clearly enough, and certain cuts seem to signify further plot developments which never materialise.

Nevertheless, this is one of the finest films I have seen in a while now, and I think this one may go on to become a classic. You read it here first. If you’ve been living under a rock.

Rate this review at LouderVoice

11 Responses to “Did anyone else think the editing at the end of ‘No Country…’ got a bit sloppy?”

  1. Green Ink Says:

    I don’t agree on the editing, I loved the movie but I thought the CGI was very ropey.

  2. Frank (author) Says:

    You’re just trying to mess with my mind, right?

  3. Green Ink Says:

    No! The pronghorn antelope in the desert were CGI.

  4. Frank (author) Says:

    Ah… I may have been getting my popcorn when they were on… :(

  5. Green Ink Says:

    Llewelyn is shooting them before he finds the dead Mexicans and the money. And you LEAVE a movie to get popcorn?

  6. Frank (author) Says:

    Nah, truth is my buddy ran late and then we hit every red light on the way to the only cinema still showing it… He’d seen it before so he went for the popcorn and I legged it in, but I’d missed the very start - it was right around that part, and the handcuffs scene, but I was finding a seat etc and didn’t even notice cgi…

  7. Green Ink Says:

    I’m a bit Woody Allen in that regard; if the film’s already started I can’t go in.

  8. Frank (author) Says:

    I’m kind of similar myself, but I was afraid it was my last chance to see it… only left in one cinema in Cork and it was Thursday night which meant they might lose it the next day… I do hate being late for the cinema though.

  9. Green Ink Says:

    You were probably hobbling anyway. How is the knee?

  10. Frank (author) Says:

    Still fucked… it’s locked. Had an mri scan eventually, and first specialist appointment is next week. Any other country I’d be walking normally by now more than likely…

  11. David Says:

    Is there someone who can explain the ending of the movie? Especially the part where he talks about his dream.
    Don’t get that part!

Leave a Reply

Feed for all entries Entries (RSS)

Feed for comments Comments (RSS).

60 queries. 0.261 seconds.

Powered by WordPress