The Lives of Others

May 9th, 2007 by Eoin

The Lives of Others tells the story of the Stasi agent Gerd Wiesler, played by Ulrich Mühe, and his investigation of the playwright Georg Dreyman (Sebastian Koch) in East Germany before the fall of the Berlin wall. While the trailer tries to make it out to be a tense thriller it is more of a character study than anything else.

livesofothers.jpg

At the very heart of the film is the eventual disillusionment of Agent Wiesler. By listening to and watching Dreyman’s life, Wiesler becomes aware of what he is missing out on in his own serious and self disciplined life. Although his moment of change was a little sudden Mühe’s performance - which was a cross between Ben Kingsley and Kevin Spacey - and the film as a whole were able to make up for it.

Fear and paranoia run throughout the film with everyone being a suspect for the Stasi and nobody knowing who to trust. It was hard not to draw parallels with modern day, especially the current USA administration. I found myself wondering what message the director had for us and why he would want to draw parallels with the US? I came to realise though that it was just the media focus on the US that made me draw parallels with it. The message of the film is as relevant to our own society here in Ireland as it is to any other country in the World.

The message of this film made it a surprise winner in the Best Foreign Film category at this year’s Oscars. Surprisingly enough there was no controversy beforehand or afterwards. I believe this was because Pan’s Labyrinth was the favourite and not too many people were familiar with The Lives of Others. Having seen them both I have to agree with the choice the Academy made.
3158.jpg
The Lives of Others marks the feature debut for writer/director Florian Henckel von Donnersmarck. It shows us a successful and talented playwright and the love of his life, an equally successful and talented actress. Their happy lives are put at risk by the invasion of the state in their domestic and private affairs. Surely the message to everyone is to be careful about who you give power to. Oh, if only there was an election on?

*The Lives of Others is now showing in The Kino on Washinton Street, Cork.*

5 Responses to “The Lives of Others”

  1. Frank Says:

    :D nice.

    Great film - had it’s flaws (as you and I have discussed) but it was just such a relief to be watching a film with merit… it’s been a while.

  2. Eoin (author) Says:

    Just realised I forgot to put in whether I liked it or not! :D It’s one of the best film I’ve seen so far in 2007. I’d recommend it to everyone.

    Off the top of my head only Science of Sleep can rival it.

  3. martin Says:

    Saw it a while back in Germany. I thought it was ok, a bit stylised in parts, although the characterisation of the main Stasi agent very was good. Little things like how he didn’t follow up on the boy in the elevator and how he started to live vicariously through the couple he was spying on. If you’re interested in other DDR type films, Der Tote Kakadu, is well worth watching. It has the same themes almost as Leben Des Andere, but much more youthful, colourful and vibrant.

  4. Frank Says:

    I was amazed at the humour in it too… I didn’t expect so many laughs when I went in…

  5. martin Says:

    Sorry, the other film dealing with the DDR and the Stasi is Der Rote Kakadu, not Der Tote Kakadu. One is red, the other is dead.

Leave a Reply

Feed for all entries Entries (RSS)

Feed for comments Comments (RSS).

60 queries. 0.240 seconds.

Powered by WordPress